$58.5M mortgage on Manhattan church, one of three filed together
A $58,538,870 mortgage on a Manhattan church parcel was recorded Nov. 17, alongside two more church mortgages totaling $64.7M from the same lender.
Last verified · How we report · Report a correction

- Source Briefing
- Public record
A $58,538,870 mortgage on a Manhattan church parcel was recorded in ACRIS on Nov. 17, 2026. The borrower is The Church of Saint Michael and the lender is Madison Investor I, LLC. The parcel is block 731, lot 53. The document is dated Nov. 5.
Two more church mortgages from the same lender were recorded the same day, which makes this a package rather than a single loan.
Who's lending and buying in New York. Free, every weekday.
Why it matters
Houses of worship rarely borrow at this scale, and large church mortgages almost never show up in the public record. Three recorded on one day, to one lender, tell brokers and lenders that a coordinated financing is moving through Manhattan religious property. For anyone who tracks institutional land in the borough, this is a new set of encumbered parcels to watch.
A trade outlet has linked a group of Manhattan church mortgages to the Archdiocese of New York. The recorded documents we pulled name the individual parish corporations and do not mention the Archdiocese, so we are not attributing the loans to it. We have not confirmed the purpose of the borrowing.
The numbers
The City Register shows three mortgages, each dated Nov. 5 and recorded Nov. 17:
- The Church of Saint Michael, $58,538,870, block 731, lot 53.
- The Church of St. Mary, $36,270,390, block 341, lot 30.
- Roman Catholic Church of Saint Brigid and, $28,425,930, blocks 390, lots 1 and 5.
Together the three come to about $123.2 million. The lender is named as Madison Investor I, LLC on the Saint Michael filing and Madison Investor 1, LLC on the other two. We found no record naming who stands behind that entity, so we do not name an ultimate lender.
What’s next
The public record does not show loan terms, rates or maturity, and the recorded mortgages do not say whether more church parcels are involved. Additional filings could still be recorded, and we will watch ACRIS for them. Related coverage of the city’s property financing is in New York.
On the record
A $58,538,870 mortgage on block 731, lot 53 in Manhattan, dated Nov. 5 and recorded Nov. 17, 2026, names The Church of Saint Michael as borrower and Madison Investor I, LLC as lender
Public record · a836-acris.nyc.gov
Primary record
- Public recordTwo further church mortgages, $36,270,390 and $28,425,930, were recorded the same day to the same lenderView the record on a836-acris.nyc.gov
- NYC ACRIS City RegisterMortgage, Roman Catholic Church of Saint Brigid and, to Madison Investor 1, LLC, $28,425,930