Cap rate, value and the 25bp move
The cap rate is the number every stabilized deal is priced on, and the one that moves fastest when rates do. Enter the NOI and the price, add the cap rate you think the market will pay, and this shows the value and how sensitive it is.
Net operating income divided by price. The unlevered year-one return a buyer accepts at this price.
The same NOI capitalized at 5.75%, which is −$3,043,478 against the price entered.
The formula
Worked with the defaults on this page: $2,700,000 ÷ $50,000,000 = 5.40%. The same NOI at a5.75% cap rate is worth $2,700,000 ÷ 0.0575 = $46,956,522. If the market cap rate rises from5.40% to 5.65%, value falls to $47,787,611, a loss of $2,212,389; if it falls to5.15%, value rises to $52,427,184, a gain of $2,427,184.
The two moves are not symmetrical. Because value is a division, a cap rate decline adds more value than an equal rise takes away, and the lower the starting cap rate, the bigger each 25 basis points is worth.
What the number means
A cap rate is the price of a dollar of stabilized income. At a 5.4 cap a buyer is paying about $18.50 for every dollar of NOI; at a 6.4 cap the same dollar is worth about $15.60. That is the whole mechanism by which rising interest rates reprice real estate: rents and expenses barely move in a quarter, but the multiple buyers will pay for the income does.
The cap rate is also a statement about growth and risk. A low cap rate means the buyer expects the income to grow, or considers it unusually safe, or both. A high cap rate means the buyer wants more income today because they doubt the future, the building, the tenant or the market.
How professionals use it
- Developers use it at both ends of a project: the exit cap rate sets what the finished building is worth, and the gap between that and yield on cost is the development spread that justifies the risk of building.
- Brokers price listings and broker opinions of value off comparable cap rates, then defend the NOI that goes on top of them.
- Lenders size loans from appraised value, which is NOI capitalized at a market cap rate, so a 25 basis point move in the appraisal cap can change loan proceeds by millions.
- Investors run the sensitivity in this tool on every exit assumption, because the exit cap rate usually drives more of the projected return than any rent assumption.
Where it misleads
The cap rate is only as honest as the NOI underneath it. A seller's NOI that leaves out a management fee, a capital reserve or a reassessed property tax bill can make a 5.0 cap look like a 5.6. Florida and Texas both reassess on sale, so a buyer's year-one taxes can be far above the seller's trailing number; underwrite the reassessed figure before quoting a cap.
It also ignores everything after year one. Two buildings at the same cap rate can have very different futures if one has below-market leases rolling next year and the other has a large tenant leaving. And it says nothing about debt: when the cost of borrowing is above the cap rate, leverage reduces the cash yield instead of increasing it.
Frequently asked
- What is a cap rate?
- A capitalization rate is a property's annual net operating income divided by its price or value. A building that produces $2.7 million of NOI and sells for $50 million trades at a 5.4 percent cap rate. It is a snapshot of the unlevered return a buyer is accepting in year one, before debt service and before any growth.
- Which NOI should I use, trailing or forward?
- Be explicit about it, because the same building can quote two very different cap rates. Trailing twelve month NOI shows what the asset actually did; forward or year-one NOI shows what the buyer expects it to do. Brokers often quote the forward number, which flatters the cap rate when rents are rising or a lease-up is unfinished. Compare cap rates only when the NOI basis matches.
- Why does a 25 basis point move matter so much?
- Because value is NOI divided by the cap rate, and dividing by a small number is sensitive. At a 5.4 cap, a 25 basis point move changes value by roughly 4 to 5 percent. On a leveraged deal with 60 percent debt, that becomes a 10 to 12 percent swing in the equity, which is often most of a sponsor's promoted profit.
- Is a cap rate the same as yield on cost?
- No. A cap rate prices an existing, stabilized asset at the price someone pays for it. Yield on cost divides stabilized NOI by what it cost to build. The difference between the two, the development spread, is the reason to build rather than buy.