The American Developer
TUE 10.13.202630-YR 7.40%10-YR 5.210.03HOMEBUILDERS 0.77%Newsletter
★ DEAL BOARDBETA751 active casescases  ·   · $317.2M in play  ·  52 sold, 30 days  ·  filed here first, from the county recordOpen the board →

Ex-Morgan Stanley CEO Asks $80M for Townhouse Bought at $13.5M

The ask would beat the $77.1M record set at 14 East 67th Street in 2019. The city's deed index shows what the sellers paid and who sold it to them.

·1 min
$80MAsking price, 165 East 70th Street
$13.5M2009 deed price (ACRIS)
5.9xAsk versus 2009 deed

John Mack, the former Morgan Stanley chief executive, and his wife, Christy, have listed their townhouse at 165 East 70th Street for $80 million, 5.9 times the $13.5 million recorded on the 2009 deed. At that price it would top the $77.1 million paid for 14 East 67th Street in 2019 and become the most expensive townhouse sale in New York City history.

Why it matters

A townhouse ask this high tests how deep the top of the Manhattan market is, because only a handful of buyers can pay it and no one has ever closed above $77.1 million. The listing is with The Agency. The city deed record shows the buyer in 2009 was MKAP, LLC, which bought from Oak Spring Farms, LLC, and the price was $13.5 million. Christy Mack has described the building’s past: “It still had the horse ramps and stalls, like a barn.” The ask is a record bid, not a record sale, and it stays an ask until a deed is recorded.

The numbers

The gap from $13.5 million to $80 million is $66.5 million, before renovation costs the records do not show. The ask beats the 2019 record by $2.9 million, or about 3.8%. City PLUTO data counts 13,024 square feet of building on a 3,280-square-foot lot built in 1902, which works out to roughly $6,100 per building square foot. Listing coverage describes nearly 16,000 square feet, which would put the ask near $5,000, so the per-foot figure depends on whose area is used.

What’s next

Watch for a price change or a contract. A closing near $80 million would reset the townhouse ceiling, while a cut would show how far the ask runs ahead of buyers. The recorded deed will be the proof either way. More: New York →

On the record

Primary record

  • Public recordThe city deed index shows the sellers' purchase: ACRIS document 2009082400621001, a deed from Oak Spring Farms, LLC to MKAP, LLC, dated August 19, 2009 and recorded August 28, 2009, at $13,500,000. The $80M ask is 5.9 times that price, or $66.5M above it.View the record on a836-acris.nyc.gov
  • Public recordCity PLUTO data lists 13,024 square feet of building area on 3,280 square feet of land (block 1405, lot 28, built 1902). At the $80M ask that is about $6,100 per building square foot by the city's count; the listing describes nearly 16,000 square feet, which would put the ask near $5,000.View the record on zola.planning.nyc.gov

Also reported by

How we report →

Get tomorrow's Index

Every notable filing, deal, and approval in US development, ranked, in one three‑minute read each morning. Free.

Your editions (pick any, optional)